You are here

A Case for Irony (Tanner Lectures on Human Values) by Jonathan Lear

By Jonathan Lear

In 2001, Vanity Fair declared that the Age of Irony was once over. Joan Didion has lamented that the U.S. within the period of Barack Obama has turn into an "irony-free zone." Jonathan Lear in his 2006 booklet Radical Hope regarded into America’s center to invite how may perhaps we dispose ourselves if we got here to believe our lifestyle used to be coming to an finish. the following, he mobilizes a squad of philosophers and a psychoanalyst to once more forge a thorough means ahead, by means of arguing that no surely human existence is feasible with out irony.

Becoming human shouldn't be taken with no consideration, Lear writes. it truly is anything we accomplish, anything we get the dangle of, and prefer Kierkegaard and Plato, Lear claims that irony is without doubt one of the crucial instruments we use to do that. For Lear and the individuals in his Socratic discussion, irony isn't approximately being cool and indifferent like a participant in a Woody Allen movie. That, as Johannes Climacus, one in every of Kierkegaard’s pseudonymous authors, places it, “is anything basically assistant professors assume.” as a substitute, it's a renewed dedication to residing heavily, to experiencing each disruption that shakes us out of our ordinary methods of tuning out of lifestyles, with all its vicissitudes. whereas many over the centuries have argued another way, Lear claims that our emotions and wishes have a tendency towards order, a constitution that irony shakes us into seeing. Lear’s exchanges along with his interlocutors increase his claims, whereas his reports as a practising psychoanalyst carry an emotionally gripping measurement to what's at stake—the psychic charges and advantages of dwelling with irony.

Show description

Read or Download A Case for Irony (Tanner Lectures on Human Values) PDF

Best psychoanalysis books

Castration (Ideas in Psychoanalysis)

From style to soccer, in our goals and epiphanies, via jealous rages and moments of genius, the results of castration anxiousness, so claims Ivan Ward, are ever-present. Freud's well-known 'castration complicated' is met with consistently in analytic adventure. but it sort of feels a fantastic suggestion. Taking his facts from delusion, scientific perform and the sexual theories of kids, Freud validated the castration advanced as one of many settling on elements of human sexual hope and character improvement.

Time in Practice: Analytical Perspectives on the Times of Our Lives

This publication is an unique exploration of the significance within the analytical courting of an attentiveness to lived, unsleeping and subconscious reviews of time in its 3 dimensions. It significantly discusses the varied options of time implied in several writings within the psychoanalytic culture, specifically these of Freud, Jung, Klein, Lacan, and Winnicott.

Time Present and Time Past: Selected Papers

"This is a unprecedented choice of papers by means of a rare psychoanalyst. Pearl King has contributed to psychoanalysis, as analyst, instructor, office-bearer, author and, no longer least, as a stimulating and clever colleague, for greater than 5 a long time. " -- Ken Robinson from the IntroductionThis awesome selection of papers is split into 3 sections: medical concerns; psychoanalysis and the lifestyles cycle; and the underlying theories.

Relational Psychoanalysis, Volume 5: Evolution of Process

Development at the good fortune and value of 3 past volumes, Relational Psychoanalysis keeps to extend and strengthen the relational flip. less than the prepared editorship of Lewis Aron and Adrienne Harris, and comprised of the contributions of the various top voices within the relational global, Volume 5 includes at the legacy of this wealthy and different psychoanalytic strategy via taking a clean examine the development in healing strategy.

Additional resources for A Case for Irony (Tanner Lectures on Human Values)

Sample text

And, of course, the recognition of the meaning of the oracle represents more than an increase in propositional knowledge—for Â�example, that I am the one who murdered his father [â•… 15â•… ] t h e l e c t u r e s and married his mother. It is the occasion for a more or less massive disruption of my sense of who I am; and a disorientation in a world that, until now, had been familiar. With this robust form of irony, the movement is in the opposite direction: a person gives a familiar designation to himself.

But if, in one’s blinkered view, Â�social pretense is all there is, then it is easy to view irony as it regularly is viewed. “Lear hasn’t handed in his grades—typical; and now he’s jabbering on about not knowing how to grade. Of course he knows how to grade; he’s just being ironic. ” To the socially embedded, it is precisely this manifestation [â•… 19â•… ] t h e l e c t u r e s of commitment that will appear as lack of commitment—perhaps as dissembling or as sarcasm. ) If we get away from misleading appearance, and try to capture what is Â�really going on with me, the language that suggests itself is that of Platonic Eros: I am struck by teaching—by an intimation of its goodness, its fundamental significance—and am filled with longing to grasp what it is and incorporate it into my life.

40 I take the mature Kierkegaard to be making fun of himself as a young man: The Concept of Irony, his Magister’s thesis, was written too much under the influence of Hegel, and thus focused one-sidedly on the negativity of irony. What we need to understand is how ironic activity can be as affirming as it is negating. Certainly, we need a better understanding of how it Â�could be that, though he spends his life undermining each particular pretense to virtue, Socrates never falls into nihilism, questioning the reality of human virtue.

Download PDF sample

Rated 4.59 of 5 – based on 3 votes